South Africa 2015 violations & victories
April 9

Journalist held for hours after
cell phone picture of Metro
policeman detaining motorist
Pretoria Rekord journalist Eliot
Mahlase was detained for hours
by the Tshwane Metro police and
forced to delete pictures he had
taken with his cell phone of a
policeman stopping and detaining
a motorist, presumably for
alleged reckless driving. Mahlase
said the police manhandled the
motorist. He was shocked when a
policeman he had photographed
tried to push him into the back
of a police van. He protested he
was not a criminal and that he
had taken the pictures legally in a
public street. He was taken to the
Garsfontein police station where
he was ordered to delete the
pictures from the phone and hand
the phone to the officer. After a
senior member of the Rekord staff
had intervened he was released
some hours later. He lodged a
formal complaint with the metro
police and laid a criminal charge.
At a meeting between the editor
and deputy editor with the Metro
police on April 14 the TMPD
promised to investigate. Later they
disputed Mahlase’s allegations.
The outcome is not known.

April 15

Policeman deletes cell phone
picture of police acting against
looters
After using his cellphone to take
pictures of police acting against
looters in Jeppestown, Johannesburg, Eyewitness News reporter
Thembekile Mrototo was forced
by a police officer to hand over

the phone. The officer deleted the
pictures and then handed back the
phone. The officer was not wearing his police badge.

April 19

Photographer’s front page picture
of man being butchered shocks
readers
Sunday Times senior photographer
James Oatway filming rioting in
Alexandra Township, Johannesburg, captured a violent attack by
a group of men on Mozambican
shopkeeper Emmanuel Sithole
who was butchered with knives,
beaten with a heavy wrench and
left for dead. He died shortly afterwards. Oatway’s picture, which
appeared on the front page of the
paper, shocked readers. He was
asked whether he should have
tried to save the man, but Oatway,
clearly worried about his own
safety, said there wasn’t time and
he did what he was expected to do
and that was to show people what
was happening.

April 21

Striking taxi drivers order
journalists to drive off `if you
don’t want to die’
A reporting team from the Daily
Sun covering riots by taxi drivers
in Cape Town where two Golden
Arrow buses had been set on fire
were assaulted and abused by the
drivers. Reporter Mandla Mnyakama and photographer Lulekwa
Mbadamane parked their car near
one of the burning buses and as
they got out were stormed by 20
men armed with bricks who demanded to know why they were
taking pictures. They searched the

Select target paragraph3