SECTOR 4

4.5 Journalists and media houses have integrity and
are not corrupt
South African journalists were generally considered to be ethical, credible and
trustworthy, particularly those working in the print media.
‘In general, journalists are pretty honest and don’t succumb to “brown envelope”
corruption.’
‘There are just a handful of people in the media with little integrity and who are
quite corrupt.’
Motoring journalists were noted for taking ‘freebies’ (such as the free use of
cars) from vehicle companies in return for positive reports. Some media houses
had codes of ethics, which prescribed, for example, the policies around gifts, but
whether these policies were practised across the board was questionable.
‘Most media houses have “freebie” policies, whereby journalists are not allowed
to accept gifts of more than 300 ZAR [21 USD]. Previously, this was 50 ZAR [3
USD]. “Soft news” journalists do tend to pocket freebies, such as cell phones,
and this is a blight on our media.’
amaBhungane has a strict no-freebie policy and refused a trip to the Wild Coast
offered by the South African Social Security Agency when it was embroiled in the
Cash Paymaster Services scandal in 2017.
It was also noted that print publications do not always make a clear distinction
between an advertorial and hard news, and it is not always clear whether travel
stories, for example, were sponsored trips. ‘You generally don’t read bad travel
reviews.’
In addition, those who have been found guilty of printing erroneous information
by the Press Council’s Press Ombudsman and have been ordered to publish
apologies, have done so. Mention was made of a 2015 incident involving the
Sunday Times publishing a full-page retraction following an ‘unfair article it
published on an alleged “rogue spy unit” within SARS [South African Revenue
Service]’. While this is positive, it was noted that the the incorrect versions are
often still available online, which was considered a problem.
In terms of media houses, the ANN7 and The New Age (both now defunct) were
highlighted as being problematic with regard to corruption, while the SABC was
noted for largely having dealt with significant issues of corruption in recent years.
It was, however, claimed that ‘it’s well known that if you want to broadcast a
“soapie” on the SABC, you have to bribe someone...the board is aware of this
problem’.

55

AFRICAN MEDIA BAROMETER SOUTH AFRICA 2018

Select target paragraph3