1.2.

The right to freedom of expression is practised and citizens, including
journalists, are asserting their rights without fear.

ANALYSIS:
Citizens’ right to freedom of expression - enshrined in both the Constitution and the Press Law
– is from time to time practised. For example, there have been protests recently against skyrocketing fuel prices: citizens expressed their freedom of expression without fear of reprisals.
But these are exceptions. The rule is repression of freedom of expression. One of the reasons
for this state of affairs might be the decades of one-party rule in the country before the Peace
Accord in 1992: some officials have yet to break out of the one-party mould as they still
consider opposing views as antagonistic.
By and large, most people do not know that the right to freedom of expression is a constitutionally enshrined right.
SCORES:
Individual scores:
Average score:

1.3

3, 3, 4, 4, 2, 3, 3, 2, 3
3.0

There are no laws restricting freedom of expression such as excessive
official secret or libel acts, or laws that unreasonably interfere with the
responsibilities of media.

ANALYSIS:
There is no overt restriction of freedom of expression. The Press Law guarantees a certain
degree of freedom except in relation to national security. In that regard it is necessary to come
up with a clear and unambiguous definition of a state secret. Foreign affairs also seems to be a
no-go area for journalists.
There is a gap between the intention of the Press Law and reality. For example, although in
other businesses foreign investors are allowed to own - in some cases - more than 50 percent of
shares in companies, this is not the case in the media industry. The Press Law limits foreign
participation in a media outlet to a 20 percent stake – this is seen as discouraging direct foreign
private investment in the sector.
Another form of restriction is that of special treatment of the media in cases of breaching the
law. While offences perpetrated by citizens fall under the common Penal Code, offences by the
media seem to be governed by their own code and are considered urgent by the courts: cases
based on allegations of slander or libel are usually rushed through the courts.
SCORES:
Individual scores:
Average score:

1.4

4, 2, 3, 4, 3, 4, 3, 5, 2
3.3

Entry into and practice of the journalistic profession is legally
unrestricted.

.
ANALYSIS:
So This Is Democracy? 2005

-209-

Media Institute of Southern Africa

Select target paragraph3