Violations against the media
According to the annual Reporters Without Boarders
(RSF) World Press Freedom Index, countries in the
Southern African region recorded a general decline in
press freedom, with an escalation of attacks against the
media.
While some Southern African countries moved up and
down the global rankings, Angola, Botswana, Malawi
and Zambia recorded improved media freedom
environments in their countries. The most improved
country in terms of media freedom ranking was Malawi,
which moved up seven places from being ranked 69 in
2020 to 62 in 2021.
While a number of media violations were recorded in
2020, RSF noted that the enactment of the Access to
Information law in Malawi was a positive sign that the
operating environment for the media was improving.
Zambia gained five places, moving to 115 from 120 in
2020. Despite the progress, RSF pointed out that as the
country moved towards elections in August that year,
the government moved to restrict media freedom.
Zambia enacted the Cyber Security and Cyber Crimes
Act, which is widely seen as having a chilling effect on
freedom of expression. Furthermore, an academic,
Sishuwa Sishuwa, faced charges of sedition for an
article that was published in a local newspaper.
Angola was also a notable gainer, moving three places
up from 106 to 103. Botswana gained one place from
39 to 38, while Eswatini remained on position 141 while
Tanzania remained unmoved at 124.
Mozambique, which was ranked 104 in 2020, fell to 108
in 2021. The country’s journalist, Ibrahimo Mbaruco,
remains unaccounted for more than a year after he
disappeared, with little indication that the government
is doing much to locate him. An insurgency in northern
Mozambique has seen an increase in media violations in
that country.
Zimbabwe is another country that slid on the rankings,
falling from 126 to 130.
While there have been some improvements such as the
enactment of the Freedom of Information Act, the onset
of the COVID-19 pandemic saw Zimbabwe tightening
media regulations.
The RSF reported that Zimbabwe had “positioned itself
between Nigeria and Uganda on the podium of Africa’s
most repressive countries with regard to the coverage of
the coronavirus crisis”.
Africa’s highest-ranked country, Namibia fell one place
from 23 to 24, while Lesotho moved down two places
from 88. South Africa fell one place from 32 to 31.

These findings were echoed by the inaugural State of
Press Freedom in Southern Africa Report, which was
commissioned by MISA. The report noted that there had
been some improvements in the state of media freedom
and a reduction in media violations in some countries,
but generally, the state of press freedom in the region
continued to be on the decline.
In 2021, MISA was particularly concerned with the rapid
deterioration of the freedom of expression environment
in Eswatini. To that end, in June 2021, MISA wrote a
letter to King Mswati III expressing its disquiet with the
media freedom environment in that country.
In the letter, MISA pointed out that there had been a
marked increase in the harassment, intimidation and
physical violence against journalists, which resulted in
almost constant self-censorship.
In addition, MISA pointed out that Zweli Dlamini, the
editor of the Swazi News, had been forced into exile in
South Africa. Eugene Dube, another journalist, has also
been forced into exile in South Africa and was unable
to practise his trade in Eswatini. Dlamini and Dube’s
“crimes” were that of writing articles deemed to be too
critical of the King.
MISA also expressed concern that the Monarchy had
filed court papers in South Africa seeking to stop
Eswatini publications from publishing stories on the
King, his family and associates without their prior
consent.
MISA reminded the King that Section 24 of the Eswatini
Constitution promotes freedom of expression, although
this right remained elusive for media workers in that
country. MISA further reminded the King of the revised
principles of the African Commission on Human and
Peoples’ Rights (ACHPR) Declaration on Freedom of
Expression and Access to Information. The Declaration
expressly calls on African governments to promote
freedom of expression and of the media in their
respective countries.
The year 2021 was a rollercoaster for Tanzania, as
it witnessed a transition, following the death of
President John Magufuli, who was succeeded by
the incumbent, President Samia Suluhu Hassan.
Magufuli’s administration was tough on the media,
with organisations regularly forced to shut down, while
Hassan promised to allow more democracy in the
media space.
To illustrate this, in January 2021, authorities in
Tanzania suspended Wasafi TV from broadcasting for six
months for allegedly violating broadcasting regulations
during a live show. This came on the backdrop of the
violations witnessed during the previous year where
several broadcasters and media houses had their
licences revoked over a slew of allegations. This was all

MISA Regional 2021 Annual 2021 Report

7

Select target paragraph3