SECTOR 1

Following the killing of 44 striking miners by police at Marikana in August 2012,
and the subsequent commission of investigation into the massacre, a number of
journalists reporting on the subject received threatening phone calls.
The few brave journalists who are tackling government on certain promises it has
made were noted by the panel, but they are definitely in the minority.
Journalists at the state broadcaster, the South African Broadcasting Corporation
(SABC), seem particularly fearful to express themselves. They do not want to
be seen to go against instructions from their bosses, but neither do they want
to be branded as opposition supporters (i.e. the Democratic Alliance [DA]) and
unpatriotic by their colleagues.
“It is becoming a culture now. Certain things are just not mentioned.”
A few civil society organisations also feel they cannot express their ideas freely
without fear. This is especially true of smaller projects that depend on government
funding.
“They fear that if they speak out and actively campaign for certain controversial
ideals, they will suffer by being branded opposition supporters, and will thus lose
out on funding, especially in the health and education sector.”
Very worrying is the comment that even members of parliamentary monitoring
groups are forewarned not to raise certain issues “because parliament can make
your lives very difficult”.
Fears are particularly strong in rural areas where patriarchy plays a very dominant
role. This was evident during hearings about the Traditional Courts Bill, where
people did not feel free to express themselves in what is a supposed “participative
democracy”.
However, the growth in social media appears to be the “game changer” for
freedom of expression, with citizens commonly speaking their minds. Sometimes,
however, this happens to an extreme degree and in a thoughtless way, leading
to possible retribution. Hawks10 spokesman, McIntosh Polela, for example, was
fired in May 2013 for recklessly publishing on Twitter the previous year: “I trust
Jub Jub’s supporters gave him a jar of Vaseline to take to prison.” Molemo ‘Jub
Jub’ Maarohanye, a famous musician, was sentenced to 25 years in prison for
murdering four schoolchildren while drag racing.

10 The Hawks is a Unit within the Police’s Directorate for Priority Crime Investigations.

16

AFRICAN MEDIA BAROMETER SOUTH AFRICA 2013

Select target paragraph3