https://zimbabwe.misa.org

Impact of Covid 19 on Media Sustainability

and that this is something all journalists need
to contemplate.

ownership has proved effective in Namibia not
in Zimbabwe. Trust ownership was used for the
English-language press during apartheid as well.
Local trusts could mobilize State funding, donor
funding, individual donations to support media.
The key is total transparency. Transparency is
also needed in state funding of media, and here
the push should be for greater transparency
and accountability of budgets, especially on
spending. South Africa often comes in the middle
of various ratings and rankings of countries but
excels in budget transparency, being right at the
top of the Open Budget Index.127 All countries in
the region need to improve their transparency
and accountability on state spending. This is
particularly pertinent to the way media is funded
by the state, since state funding of media should be
equitable rather than a means of control through
skewed advertising or other support. The use
of advertising as a means of supporting media
is not justifiable anyway, because government
advertising should be justified on the grounds
of achieving state goals such as, for example, job
advertising to find the right person for the job.

What donor funding does not achieve is
creation of organisations with a capital base
and a sense of ownership, two things that from
my own experience I think has helped the
Mail & Guardian, formerly the Weekly Mail,
news organisation survive the disappearance
of funding for what was called “alternative”
news media in the 1980s. Other alternative
publications such as Vrye Weekblad closed their
doors. A company enables the sale of equity to
raise capital. As a company, The Weekly Mail
could sell a stake to the UK Guardian group
(hence the name Mail & Guardian). A strong
capital base is also important in protection of
news organisations against strategic lawsuit
against public participation (SLAPP) legal suits
or law fare. In the straitened circumstances
news media find themselves in the region, a
lack of capital could mean a winner-takes-all
consolidation, reducing media plurality. Stateowned organization can turn to the state for
recapitalization and where the state is major or
only shareholder, it is incumbent on the state
to set aside such money. Donors must consider
funding for-profit media and all media must
look at hybrid models that allow donor funding
in emergencies.
Perhaps a regional fund for journalism could
be set up after careful consideration of how
to insulate it from political pressures, with a
mandate for enhancing financial sustainability,
including looking at trusts. The trust model of

Contributions to a properly independent body
which could then decide on funding according
to a formula could be an option. However,
one argument against state funding is that it
does not make space for startups providing
media plurality at the organizational level
and experimentation creating diversity at the
audience level. The Dutch government devotes
money specifically to innovation and is an idea
worth pursuing.128

127. “Open Budget Survey (OBS) 2019 Key Findings” (International Budget Partnership, 2020).
128. “What the Dutch Journalism Fund is here for,” Stimuleringsfonds voor de Journalistiek (blog), accessed August 7, 2020, https://
www.svdj.nl/dutch-journalism-fund/.

39

Select target paragraph3