Impact of Covid 19 on Media Sustainability

https://zimbabwe.misa.org

the inversion Prof Harber refers to is that donor
funding is regarded as fickle and often having
strings attached. One way of avoiding this
diversifying revenue streams, as Daily Maverick
aims to do, or the amaBhungane approach of
limiting funding from any one donor, and by
reaching out to the public. Nonetheless, the
question must be asked about the limits of the nonprofit model for funding, not the investigative
journalism that for-profits find difficult to afford,
but the ordinary coverage of public and private
life that has been the mainstay of newspapers,
not grand corruption but “politics, prices and
princes”; court reporting, local government
and governance, crime, finance and inflation.
And while donors have come forth to put money
forward for journalism, the demands of society
in general in the time of Covid-19 economic
upheaval are enormous.

“I think the world is open now for a bit more
of a social democratic approach to media
development and maintenance of what exists.
The problem with state support, however, is that
you are only going to be looking at fighting over
a share of the overall tax pool.”121

The same problem faces those who proffer
government subsidies in some form as at least
part of the answer. Guy Berger of UNESCO points
out that resistance to government funding of
journalism has faded as the financial problems
of news media have intensified:
“The debate about the necessity of noncommercial funding the media comes about as
Covid has shaken up our ideas of what’s possible.
Even in the US, those who used to oppose any
idea of public funding and who were firmly in
favour of liberal media development, are now
ready to accept some form of intervention may
be necessary, and are recognizing that public
funds for public service media such as NPR are
critical.

The answer he looks for is somehow to use some
of the extraordinary revenues the internet giants
manage to extract to support local media, as has
been proposed, for example, in Australia. Will
that be enough?
News media will be under more pressure than
before to diversify revenue streams, but too much
emphasis on this can distract from the focus of the
organisation: is the website or newspaper or radio
or TV station an event-organiser or a place where
journalism happens? The alternative revenue
stream can take over the whole organisation.
South Africa has its own example in Naspers,
which has morphed over time from a big media
house with a small internet business to a big
internet business with a small media house. The
South African Media24 subsidiary, though large
in South Africa, is a small part of Naspers multibillion-rand international operations.
Finally, while non-profits are insulated to
some extent from the kind of disaster that the
disappearance of advertising has been, the forprofit model has its merits. The Mail & Guardian
has been in business as a commercial operation
with a clear public interest mission for it would
not continue, however, without the support of
the kind of investor that has the mandate to take
the long-term view that investing in independent
media requires. MDIF

121. Berger, Interview with Guy Berger, director for Freedom of Expression and Media Development, Unesco.

34

Select target paragraph3