6RXWK$IULFD

but later caved in under pressure and
anonymous threatening phone calls. The
SACP and the ANC called for a banning
of the painting, and its members burnt
copies of City Press. Five months later, by
October 2012, Haffajee said she was manipulated; she regretted her decision to
remove the painting: “We were played,”
she said.3 The ANC had shown its pattern of paranoia its reactions. The same
pattern was evident with presidency
spokesperson, Mac Maharaj’s reaction
to Mail & Guardian accounts of alleged
corruption with transport tenders and
Swiss bank accounts.
Criminal charges against journalists: 26 July 2012: M&G editor Nic
Dawes and amaBhungane journalists
Stefaans Brummer and Sam Sole were
charged with “theft” of confidential
records and disclosing information for
which they could get 15 year sentences
after they published a story in November
2011, alleging that Maharaj and his wife
received large sums of money through the
arms deal. The hysteria moves from spurious theft charges against journalists to
pulling television programmes from the
public broadcaster, dubbed party broadcaster, (the SABC) if they are too critical.
SABC politicisation: The tension
between freedom of expression and
rights to dignity was played out when
the SABC found that popular cartoonist, Jonathan Shapiro’s “Zapiro” cartoons
were too “insulting” to President Zuma.
Hence, in the first week of December
3 She made this comment at the launch of the
book Fight for Democracy: The ANC and the Media
in SA, 10 October 2012, at Wits University, where
she was guest speaker.



6R7KLVLV'HPRFUDF\"

2012 it dropped a pre-recorded interview with the cartoonist. “We are very
sensitive about all peoples’ rights and
dignity and so we could not carry that
interview, Zapiro must do what he does
best, but we disagree and we can’t endorse his cartoons on our platform,” said
CEO Hlaudi Motsoeneng.4 Shapiro said
he was “blacklisted” for the third time.
The other two occasions were on SABC
radio: Metro FM and 5FM.
In a further SABC censorship incident, on 7 November 2012, head of news
Jimi Matthews blacklisted from his journalists from using the term “Nkandlagate” in their reports. The term described
the inordinate amount of money, about
R280-million (approximately US$30million), on Zuma’s homestead development in KwaZulu-Natal.
The SABC, the biggest media body in
the country, lurched from crisis to crisis
(management, leadership, board and financial) in 2012. This seemed to be the
position of the SOS Coalition, which
was set up to monitor the role of the
SABC, shine a light on corruption, review
broadcasting policy, and try to steer the
institution towards being a public broadcaster rather than a party mouthpiece.
Then there were new concerns when
the SABC linked hands with the ANC’s
benefactor, The New Age (TNA), to conduct what are termed “business breakfasts” which cost hundreds of thousands
and funded by mainly by State-owned
enterprises (SOEs), indirectly the State,
and therefore the taxpayer. These break4 M&G: Zapiro cartoons too insulting for SABC:
December 14-20, 2012.

Select target paragraph3